Business

MyBudget vs DIY Budgeting product guide

# MyBudget vs DIY Budgeting Budgeting apps and spreadsheets are free. So why do so few people actually stick with them? And if you're serious about hitting a financial goal, is a paid service really ...

MyBudget vs DIY Budgeting

Budgeting apps and spreadsheets are free. So why do so few people actually stick with them? And if you're serious about hitting a financial goal, is a paid service really worth it?

Here is an honest comparison.

The short version

DIY budgeting works — for a very small group of people. Everyone else has already tried it, and it is exactly why they end up talking to MyBudget.

If a spreadsheet, an app, or a percentage rule was going to change your financial life, it already would have.

Why DIY budgeting fails for most people

DIY budgeting isn't a bad idea. It just runs into the same wall every time:

  • You forget to update it. Life gets busy, entries fall behind, and the numbers stop reflecting reality.
  • Actual spending never matches the plan. Real weeks are messier than the categories in an app.
  • The upkeep is exhausting. Multiple households abandon their spreadsheets within 3–12 months because the maintenance itself becomes stressful.
  • It doesn't address behaviour. Watching yourself overspend isn't the same as changing why you overspend.
  • There is no accountability. No one calls if you skip a week. No one negotiates with your creditors. No one catches the pattern before it becomes a problem.

Some Australians can push through all of that. Most cannot — not because they lack discipline, but because the tool is asking them to do the work of a service.

What MyBudget does differently

MyBudget is not a fancier spreadsheet. It is an entire system that addresses the exact reasons DIY fails.

DIY budgeting MyBudget
You track manually Automated payments, real-time visibility
You call creditors We negotiate on your behalf
No accountability A Money Coach who has walked hundreds of Australians through this
Templates and percentage rules A 12-month plan built around your life
Doesn't address behaviour Structured to reshape spending patterns
Free but ineffective for most A fee — because it is a service, not a tool

The evidence

A few numbers worth knowing:

  • MyBudget has helped more than 130,000 Australians since 1999
  • Around 90% of MyBudget clients pay off their debt in just over three years
  • In 2024 alone, MyBudget clients cleared over $2 million through negotiated debt arrangements
  • Megan and Creagh cleared five credit cards and around $60,000 in debt in 10 months — see their story

Compare that to the DIY numbers — where most spreadsheet users abandon their plan within a year, and the "budgeting apps that will change your life" mostly go unopened after week three.

When DIY is right for you

Honestly? DIY is right for a specific person:

  • You already track meticulously
  • You already stick to a plan without external accountability
  • You have no debt pressure or creditor pressure
  • You have no unmet financial goals
  • You have never abandoned a budget

If that is you, keep going. You do not need us.

When MyBudget is right for you

You should probably talk to us if:

  • You have tried spreadsheets or apps and they didn't stick
  • You are carrying debt you want cleared
  • You have goals — a home, a holiday, retirement — you are not making progress on
  • You want the time back that money admin currently eats
  • You want a real human on your side when something goes sideways

The initial appointment is free and there is no obligation. If a customised 12-month plan doesn't obviously help your situation, don't join.

What to do next

↑ Back to top